What You Should Know
About Smoke and Fire Alarm Sensing Technologies


While all smoke alarms are designed to detect smoke, certain sensing technologies react differently to certain types of fires.

For the earliest possible warning, be sure your smoke alarms use Photoelectric Sensing Technology to provide your family with the maximum in fire-safety protection.

Photoelectric Sensing Technology

is generally more sensitive than Ionization Sensing Technology at detecting large particles, which tend to be produced in greater amounts by smoldering fires.  Sources of smoldering fires may include cigarettes burning in couches or bedding.  A fire can often smolder for hours before erupting into flames.

Ionization Sensing Technology

is generally more sensitive than Photoelectric Sensing Technology at detecting small particles, which tend to be produced in greater amounts by flaming fires. Sources of flaming fires may include paper burning in a wastebasket or a grease fire in the kitchen.  Flaming fires consume combustible materials rapidly and spread quickly.

A major problem we have found, which has been kept from the general public, is that while it’s important to note that all smoke alarms are designed to detect particles of smoke, regardless of their type, Ionization sensors used alone in smoke detectors do not react quickly enough to smoky, smoldering fires, and too many lives are lost.  Because of this, L.I.F.E.™ Support Technologies has decided that until we can determine, and a majority of our Advisory Panel has agreed, that we can utilize Ionization-sensing technology in conjunction with our current designs (but with the different detectors working independently of each other within the unit, for maximum protection) without compromising the reliability of our products, we will not manufacture smoke detectors using Ionization sensors.

ALWAYS BE SURE TO:

  • Install Photoelectric-sensing type smoke alarms on every level of your home for maximum protection.
  • Have a smoke alarm in every bedroom.
  • Test your smoke alarms every month*.
  • Change the back-up batteries in your smoke alarms every 6 months.
  • Create and practice a home escape plan at least twice a year.
  • Keep a fire extinguisher in the kitchen.

* Monthly “testing” of your smoke alarm ensures that the unit is powered, and that IF SMOKE IS DETECTED, the unit should function; however, you still need to make sure that the detector inside the unit is one that will detect smoke quickly enough to give you time to escape!

REMEMBER:

What matters is that you provide your family with the maximum in fire-safety protection for all possible conditions, so be sure your home is equipped with Photoelectric-sensing types of smoke alarms.

Our soon-to-be-released SG-9000™ smoke detectors will have the ability to detect the presence of Carbon Monoxide, in additiion to utilizing photoelectric technology to detect smoke.

Our SG-8000™ system will radically change the way buildings (whether homes or larger sites such as hotels, hospitals, schools and commercial sites) are protected, and will be the ultimate in fire protection.

For more information, please e-mail or contact us


The following data showing the different technologies used in Ionization and Photoelectric sensors is from the United States Environmental Protection Agency.  What this document fails to discuss is the unacceptable time it takes for an Ionization sensor to activate a smoke detector in time for the occupants of a structure to safely evacuate.
(Our comments are shown in blue.)

Smoke Detectors & Radiation

Smoke detectors and alarms are important home safety devices. Ionization chamber and photoelectric smoke detectors are the two most common types available commercially. Because these pages are most concerned with radiation protection, we will focus mainly on the ionization chamber technology.

Ionization chamber smoke detectors contain a small amount of radioactive material encapsulated in a metal chamber. They take advantage of the ions created by ionizing radiation to develop a low, but steady electrical current.  Smoke particles entering the chamber disrupt the current and trigger the detector's alarm.  Ionization chamber detectors react more quickly to fast flaming fires that give off little smoke.

How much radiation is in smoke detectors?

The radiation source in an ionization chamber detector is a very small disc, about 3 to 5 millimeters in diameter, weighing about 0.5 gram. It is a composite of americium-241 in a gold matrix. The average activity in a smoke detector source is about one microcurie, 1 millionth of a curie.

Americium emits alpha particles and low energy gamma rays. It has a half-life of about 432 years. The long half-life means that americium decays very slowly, emitting very little radiation. At the end of the 10 year useful life of the smoke detector, it retains essentially all its original activity.

How much radiation exposure will I get from a smoke detector?

As long as the radiation source stays in the detector, exposures would be negligible (less than about 1/100 of a millirem per year), since alpha particles cannot travel very far or penetrate even a single sheet of paper, and the gamma rays emitted by americium are relatively weak. If the source were removed, it would be very easy for a small child to swallow, but even then exposures would be very low because the source would pass through the body fairly rapidly (by contrast, the same amount of americium in a loose powdered form would give a significant dose if swallowed or inhaled). Still, its not a good idea to separate the source from the detector apparatus.

Owning and operating a smoke alarm

Regardless of the detection technology used in your smoke alarm, the product label, User's Manual or Warranty should state the expected useful life of the smoke detector. For example, smoke alarms with the UL label have been certified with an expected useful life of 10 years. The product label also will tell you whether this includes the useful life of the battery. If you do not have a lithium long life battery (10 years), fire officials recommend that you change your batteries at the same time you turn your clock back each year for the end of Daylight Saving Time.  It's also important to make sure your smoke alarm is working properly.  You should test the alarm periodically (there should be a button to press).  But be very careful if you use a source of smoke to test the detector.

It is important for everyone reading this document to understand that when you “test” a smoke or fire detector and hear the alarm, this does not mean that the detector will do the job it is supposed to do – alert you to real danger.  It simply means that the detector is receiving power, either from the building's electricity (A/C) or from the unit's battery (D/C). Testing in this manner is not testing whether the detector is doing what it states it does on the packaging! Nor is testing it from 6 inches or a foot away with a canned vapor specifically designed to activate an ionization sensor. All L.I.F.E. Support Technologies detection devices are being tested in the field under “real-life” conditions, in addition to being tested under laboratory conditions.  Laboratory testing alone is simply not sufficient when it comes to protecting your family with equipment that will function properly in your structure!

Smoke alarm and heat detector (which senses the heat from a fire to trigger an alarm or sprinkler system, but does not detect smoke) technologies are all relatively inexpensive for a homeowner. A smoke alarm can usually be purchased for $10 to $25. Many companies make separate products using either photoelectric or ionization technologies, or they combine the technologies in one product. Read the packaging and label material on the product. Smoke and heat detector technologies may also be combined with home break-in alarm equipment to provide a total home security system connected to your local fire and police services. Whether you choose an electrical or battery operated model, you must follow the manufacturer's recommendations for installation, testing and maintenance to get maximum protection.

While Ionization is better at detecting a flaming fire, these usually occur in a kitchen or other occupied space where everyone present is instantly aware of the danger.  Yes, there are instances where children playing with matches, etc., can set a fire in a bedroom or location not being observed by adults, but this is where smoke detectors, using both technologies (ionization and photoelectric, operating independently), are a good preventative solution.

Ionization Technology

Ionization sensor smoke alarms contain a small amount of radioactive material, americium embedded in a gold foil matrix within an ionization chamber. The matrix is made by rolling gold and americium oxide ingots together to form a foil approximately one micrometer thick. This thin gold-americium foil is then sandwiched between a thicker (~0.25 millimeter) silver backing and a 2 micron thick palladium laminate. This is thick enough to completely retain the radioactive material, but thin enough to allow the alpha particles to pass.

The ionization chamber is basically two metal plates a small distance apart. One of the plates carries a positive charge, the other a negative charge. Between the two plates, air molecules-made up mostly of oxygen and nitrogen atoms-are ionized when electrons are kicked out of the molecules by alpha particles from the radioactive material (alpha particles are big and heavy compared to electrons). The result is oxygen and nitrogen atoms that are positively charged because they are short one electron; the free electrons are negatively charged.

The diagrams below illustrate how ionization technology works. The positive atoms flow toward the negative plate, as the negative electrons flow toward the positive plate. The movement of the electrons registers as a small but steady flow of current. When smoke enters the ionization chamber, the current is disrupted as the smoke particles attach to the charged ions and restore them to a neutral electrical state. This reduces the flow of electricity between the two plates in the ionization chamber. When the electric current drops below a certain threshold, the alarm is triggered.

Ionization Technology

Alpha particles from the americium source ionize air molecules

In the smoke-free chamber, positive and negative ions create a small current as they migrate to charged plates

 

Smoke particles and combustion gases interact with the ions generated by the alpha particles, restoring them to their neutral electronic state and decreasing the electrical current passing through the cell.

As fewer ions are available to migrate to the plates, the disrupted current triggers the alarm

Photoelectric Technology

Photoelectric technology smoke alarms use a T-shaped chamber fitted with a light-emitting diode (LED) and a photocell. The LED sends a beam of light across the horizontal bar of the chamber. The photocell sits at the bottom of the vertical portion of the chamber. The photo cell will generate a current, when exposed to light.

The diagram below illustrates how the technology works. Under normal, smoke-free conditions, the LED beam moves in a straight line, through the chamber without striking the photo cell. When smoke enters the chamber, smoke particles deflect some of the light rays, scattering them in all directions. Some of it reaches the photocell. When enough light rays hit the photocell, they activate it. The activated photocell generates a current. The current powers the alarm, and the smoke alarm has done its job.

Photoelectric Smoke Alarm Technology

smoke free chamber
light beam travels straight through
smoke particles in chamber
deflect some light rays
light
emitting
diode

activated
photocell
powers alarm
no light reaches
photoelectric cell
deflected light rays
activate photocell

For more information, please e-mail or contact us

L.I.F.E. Support Technologies, LLC Home Page

L.I.F.E. Support Technologies ®

National Fire
Protection Association

Member # 2311302

Developed by SALA-Publishing® 2004-2011 and beyond  L.I.F.E. Support Technologies®